As a political entity the EU has evolved massively over time, beginning with a series of treaties and the creation of the'European coal and steel community' (ECSC) by five member states. A few years later the European community was created by the merging of the ECSC with the EEC (European economic community) and Euratom (European atomic energy community). At this point the 'EU' was little more than a loosely made community, and a first attempt at economic integration in Europe. More member states continued to join the EC, and in the late 80s it began to expand into a monetary union. It did this through SEA (single European act) which prepared for the establishment of a common market, as well as well as the Maastrict treaty which made the EC into an official institution (the EU), and further paved the way for the creation of a single currency. National currencies were replaced with the Euro in 2002 for some member states, while others such as the UK chose to opt out. At this point the EU had evolved from a first attempt at economic integration to a fully fledged institution with international law making abilities. The next step was to create a constitution however this failed in 2004 when referendums in France and the Netherlands indicated the public were not in favour of its ratification. Instead, the Lisbon treaty was created, implementing many of the constitutions changes in the form of amendments to existing treaties. This came into force in December 2009.
As a result of widening and deepening integration, the EU has been seen by some as a European superstate, going further than the idea of federalised Europe and ultimately destroying state sovereignty. Such people also view the EU as a rival superpower to the US, in terms of its economic and potential military power. While I would argue that the EU is no longer the intergovernmental institution of independent states that it once was, I would disagree with the idea that the EU has become a superstate. The sovereignty of member states is enshrined in the Luxembourg compromise of 1966, which gave each member state a veto on matters threatening vital national interests. However, it cannot be ignored that the ability of the EU to create laws that its member states must abide to does erode some state sovereignty, as does the introduction of qualified majority voting.
Despite the increasing centralisation within the EU there are checks in place to ensure it cannot be described as truly 'federal' - it is more accurate to talk of a federalising Europe. An example of this is the principle of subsidiarity, which ensures decisions are made as close to citizens as possible, essentially devolving power from the centre outwards.
The current nature of the EU as a political entity is an institution of economic, (and to a lesser extent, political) governance. While it is no longer confined to intergovernmentalism, it cannot be said to be a purely supranational body and as such is a blend of the two. It extends far beyond other intergovernmental institutions in that European citizens have free movement (as a result of the Schengen agreement) and many share the euro as their currency, but does not go as far as to completely erode state sovereignty or to have a common security and defence policy. While the EU has become more than the confederation of independent states it once was, it has not and may never become the 'united states of Europe' as visualised by Churchill.
Showing posts with label state sovereignty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label state sovereignty. Show all posts
Saturday, 9 January 2016
Sunday, 13 December 2015
ARE NATION STATES STILL THE MOST SIGNIFICANT ACTORS IN GLOBAL POLITICS?
When the Nation state was established in 1648, it was the most significant global actor and remained so for some 300 years. A nation state is an autonomous (independent) political community bound together by citizenship and nationality, meaning that political and cultural identity coincide. 'Nation state' has been used as a synonym for 'state' or 'country' although this is not necessarily true. The first and second world wars were very much wars of and between nation states however by the end of WW2 and the start of the cold war, emerging globalisation and the rise of NGOs and TNCs have brought into question whether or not nation states are still the most significant actors in global politics.
The growing importance of global governance institutions such as the UN suggests that nation states are not as significant as they once were. The UN has 193 member states and is able to deploy peacekeepers to state territory after a conflict, in an attempt to maintain newly established peace. It's members (general assembly) and more significantly its security council and the P5 can approve or condemn invasions and wars - a recent example saw P5 members deciding to work together to defeat ISIS (another non state actor) which has ultimately led to airstrikes in Syria. The UN security council is also able to impose sanctions and embargoes on nation states if it feels they have acted 'illegally', as with Russia's annexing of the Ukraine.
However, the UN as well as other significant global governance institutions (the three sisters), are made up of nation states and so cannot exist without the pre established member states. If significant nations states withdrew their UN membership, the UN's legitimacy and authority as a global governance institution would be severely diminished. Additionally the UN has no real sovereignty or law making power (it cannot make laws that apply to all nation states, but it can pass resolutions which have power over member states only), whereas nation states have governments with full law making power and the authority to impose these laws. The UN had no say over the US' 2003 invasion of Iraq which it saw as an illegal war, implying the US as a nation state is more powerful than the UN.
Regional institutions like the EU and NAFTA are arguably more significant than nation state actors. While the EU is made up of nation states, its members pool their state sovereignty. This effectively results in the EU having more sovereignty than its combined members and being able to assert its opinions as an influential global actor. It is able to influence trade and even fishing regulations and so has influence over the economies of nation states. The EU could be seen as an erosion of state sovereignty but its members are able to opt out and so its power is limited.
The growth of TNCs (which have become supranational in some cases) has seen corporations having enormous wealth and as a result, power as actors on the world stage. Some companies have a GDP higher than that of a nation state - Wal-mart, for example, has a higher GDP than Austria and South Africa. Moreover, TNCs create jobs wherever they decide to open stores or offices, and so the governments of nation states are forced to give them tax breaks to prevent them moving to an area which will make them more profit. TTIP, a trade deal which is currently being negotiated, would allow companies to sue national governments for imposing laws which do not allow them to optimise their profits, and would be a huge blow to state sovereignty. Additionally corporations are able to lobby governments as they have enormous wealth which can be used to influence lawmaking.
Nation states, however, provide the conditions of social order and security which TNCs need to operate so can be seen as significant actors in this way.
Informal forums like the G20 are also significant global actors, with the G20 influencing the world economy arguably more than any individual nation state would be able to. The G20 is made up of the governments of major economies (Finance Ministers) as well as Central Bank Governors and so is partly separate from the nation state. It formulated the response to the 2007-9 financial crisis and as such can be seen as having a huge influence on global politics.
The rise of terrorist organisations like ISIS and Boko Haram is another factor which suggest nation states are no longer the most significant actors in global politics. ISIS has control over vast territories in Iraq and Syria, controlling areas with 2.8 million and 8 million people, despite not being a nation state. It has gathered huge wealth and economic power as a result, with nation states such as Turkey buying its cheap oil and essentially funding the operation. The lack of success of nation states such as the US, Russia and now the UK in taking down ISIS is a testament to its power as a global actor and has worrying implications for the fate of the nation state in global politics.
The growing importance of global governance institutions such as the UN suggests that nation states are not as significant as they once were. The UN has 193 member states and is able to deploy peacekeepers to state territory after a conflict, in an attempt to maintain newly established peace. It's members (general assembly) and more significantly its security council and the P5 can approve or condemn invasions and wars - a recent example saw P5 members deciding to work together to defeat ISIS (another non state actor) which has ultimately led to airstrikes in Syria. The UN security council is also able to impose sanctions and embargoes on nation states if it feels they have acted 'illegally', as with Russia's annexing of the Ukraine.
However, the UN as well as other significant global governance institutions (the three sisters), are made up of nation states and so cannot exist without the pre established member states. If significant nations states withdrew their UN membership, the UN's legitimacy and authority as a global governance institution would be severely diminished. Additionally the UN has no real sovereignty or law making power (it cannot make laws that apply to all nation states, but it can pass resolutions which have power over member states only), whereas nation states have governments with full law making power and the authority to impose these laws. The UN had no say over the US' 2003 invasion of Iraq which it saw as an illegal war, implying the US as a nation state is more powerful than the UN.

Regional institutions like the EU and NAFTA are arguably more significant than nation state actors. While the EU is made up of nation states, its members pool their state sovereignty. This effectively results in the EU having more sovereignty than its combined members and being able to assert its opinions as an influential global actor. It is able to influence trade and even fishing regulations and so has influence over the economies of nation states. The EU could be seen as an erosion of state sovereignty but its members are able to opt out and so its power is limited.
The growth of TNCs (which have become supranational in some cases) has seen corporations having enormous wealth and as a result, power as actors on the world stage. Some companies have a GDP higher than that of a nation state - Wal-mart, for example, has a higher GDP than Austria and South Africa. Moreover, TNCs create jobs wherever they decide to open stores or offices, and so the governments of nation states are forced to give them tax breaks to prevent them moving to an area which will make them more profit. TTIP, a trade deal which is currently being negotiated, would allow companies to sue national governments for imposing laws which do not allow them to optimise their profits, and would be a huge blow to state sovereignty. Additionally corporations are able to lobby governments as they have enormous wealth which can be used to influence lawmaking.
Nation states, however, provide the conditions of social order and security which TNCs need to operate so can be seen as significant actors in this way.
The rise of terrorist organisations like ISIS and Boko Haram is another factor which suggest nation states are no longer the most significant actors in global politics. ISIS has control over vast territories in Iraq and Syria, controlling areas with 2.8 million and 8 million people, despite not being a nation state. It has gathered huge wealth and economic power as a result, with nation states such as Turkey buying its cheap oil and essentially funding the operation. The lack of success of nation states such as the US, Russia and now the UK in taking down ISIS is a testament to its power as a global actor and has worrying implications for the fate of the nation state in global politics.
Sunday, 20 September 2015
THE IMPORTANCE OF PALESTINE WHEN DEBATING SOVEREIGNTY
WHAT IS SOVEREIGNTY?
Sovereignty can be defined as the principle of absolute and unlimited power; the absence of a higher authority in either domestic or external affairs.
The concept of sovereignty is very closely related to the concept of statehood in that sovereignty is a defining characteristic of a state - states are states because they are able to exercise sovereign jurisdiction within their defined borders.
WHY IS PALESTINE INVOLVED?
In recent years, Palestine has tried to attain statehood - in September 2011 a formal request for Palestine's statehood was submitted to the United Nations. In November 2012 the general assembly of the UN voted overwhelmingly to recognize Palestine as a 'non member observer state' meaning Palestine had access to other UN bodies such as the international criminal court. When Israel was established as a state in 1948, the majority of Arab Palestinians became refugees - this problem was worsened by the six day war in 1967 in which Sinai, the Gaza strip, the West Bank and Golan Heights were occupied by Israel. The first face to face meeting between the PLO (Palestine Liberation Organisation) and the government of Israel occurred in 1993 and lay the groundwork for the establishment of the Palestinian National Authority in 1996 which assumed governmental authority (but not sovereignty) for the West Bank and the Gaza strip.
SO WHY IS PALESTINE IMPORTANT WHEN DEBATING SOVEREIGNTY?
While Israel is widely recognised as a state (it was created after the second world war when Jewish people wanted a place to live, out of land taken from the Ottoman empire), Palestine's statehood is more questionable - although many of the UN members recognise it as a state, not all of them do. In addition to this it does not really meet the requirements of a state as defined by the Montevideo convention - its defined territory is questionable and it does not necessarily have a good government (Hamas is seen by some as a terrorist organisation). State Sovereignty is when a state enjoys sovereignty in its defined border, and so Palestine cannot have state sovereignty as its territory is changing regularly and it is barely recognised as a state. On the other hand, Israel is recognised as a state but it arguably does not have state sovereignty within its own borders as part of its territory is in question and it has given some authority over decision making in these areas (the Gaza strip and the West Bank) to Palestine.
Sovereignty can be defined as the principle of absolute and unlimited power; the absence of a higher authority in either domestic or external affairs.
The concept of sovereignty is very closely related to the concept of statehood in that sovereignty is a defining characteristic of a state - states are states because they are able to exercise sovereign jurisdiction within their defined borders.
WHY IS PALESTINE INVOLVED?
In recent years, Palestine has tried to attain statehood - in September 2011 a formal request for Palestine's statehood was submitted to the United Nations. In November 2012 the general assembly of the UN voted overwhelmingly to recognize Palestine as a 'non member observer state' meaning Palestine had access to other UN bodies such as the international criminal court. When Israel was established as a state in 1948, the majority of Arab Palestinians became refugees - this problem was worsened by the six day war in 1967 in which Sinai, the Gaza strip, the West Bank and Golan Heights were occupied by Israel. The first face to face meeting between the PLO (Palestine Liberation Organisation) and the government of Israel occurred in 1993 and lay the groundwork for the establishment of the Palestinian National Authority in 1996 which assumed governmental authority (but not sovereignty) for the West Bank and the Gaza strip.
SO WHY IS PALESTINE IMPORTANT WHEN DEBATING SOVEREIGNTY?
While Israel is widely recognised as a state (it was created after the second world war when Jewish people wanted a place to live, out of land taken from the Ottoman empire), Palestine's statehood is more questionable - although many of the UN members recognise it as a state, not all of them do. In addition to this it does not really meet the requirements of a state as defined by the Montevideo convention - its defined territory is questionable and it does not necessarily have a good government (Hamas is seen by some as a terrorist organisation). State Sovereignty is when a state enjoys sovereignty in its defined border, and so Palestine cannot have state sovereignty as its territory is changing regularly and it is barely recognised as a state. On the other hand, Israel is recognised as a state but it arguably does not have state sovereignty within its own borders as part of its territory is in question and it has given some authority over decision making in these areas (the Gaza strip and the West Bank) to Palestine.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
